RTFM Avoid embarrassment.

What may happen when one is decided to have great theories about a subject he is not familiar with? Except all those irritating rhetorical turns that he produce1 sometimes there are great comical effects.

I just managed not throwing my mouthful of coffee on my laptop (but I do have to clean the floor):

While preparing this review, I found it impossible to find a description of where the lateral plates come from.

E84BE954-DEC4-45F3-8F46-6FC4ABCC9255.jpg*This is the perfect occasion to place: RTFM.

What embryology textbooks our physicist have consulted that doesn’t give the origin of the mesoderm and the subdivisions of the mesodermal plate to paraxial, intermediary and lateral? He should give us the name(s) of the book(s) to avoid it(them).

I suspect Fleury really tried hard to find where the lateral plate come from, as he emphasize “impossible“. He didn’t searched in the right place. Maybe he thought that a brilliant physicist have nothing useful to learn in an embryology textbook: wrong.

Let’s see,

  1. this guy is to discuss about gastrulation; which result in the formation of the three primary germ layers, ectoderm mesoderm (including the lateral plate) and endoderm and despite his ignorance of the gastrulation he have a theory about the origin of tetrapods which he is clarifying,
  2. somehow this blatant example of ignorance wasn’t corrected by the editor or the reviewers of the paper, leading to suspect them to be either as much ignorant as the author2 or suspect they haven’t read the paper; quite embarrassing for the journal and his editorial board.

Now, I hope Vincent Fleury is going to drop everything else he is doing right now, go to the library ASAP and get an embryology textbook to read. Read it, learn the definitions to be sure what he is talking about then read his paper for basic corrections.

1. Which could be of great interested for people like Brickmont & Sokal as they are Fashionable Nonsense.

2. Not really a problem for physicists to ignore embryology, or for embryologists to ignore some physics.

* Illustration from fruitless Splicing Specifies Male Courtship Behavior in Drosophila, in reference of Jean Staune’s opinion about biology textbooks:

Ce n’est pas en lisant un bouquin de biologie technique traitant de l’enculage des mouches que l’on peut comprendre l’évolution

Well, Staune is wrong, some basic manuals reading would have avoided much embarrassment to Fleury.


14 Responses

  1. […] avoiding to engage the discipline’s reputation on the point of view of one person; and an ill informed one as it goes. Well done, but plenty of errors persist, in the heading and in the text. […]

  2. no links to a nice illustration ?

  3. […] avril 23, 2009 par Oldcola Si un exemple de la puissance de l’utilisation de Google vous intéresse, je viens d’en poster un là. […]

  4. […] Comments anon on RTFMgoogling “late… on RTFMOldcola on RTFMOldcola on RTFManon on […]

  5. […] «… on AbstractOldcola on oops 090425n=3 on oops 090425Oldcola on RTFMStop the rotatives! … on […]

  6. […] don’t just wrongly reports other people’s work, but provide his own interpretations. He ignores where the lateral plate comes from (and this is a particularly important point for his model), explains the geometry of limb buds […]

  7. […] Oldcola Il y en a qui ne sont pas foutus de se servir de Google, et qui le font savoir de façon plus ou moins agréable, comme il y en a qui ne savent pas profiter des blogs ou se servir de […]

  8. […] Comments pas foutus « C… on RTFMOldcola on Oops 090614#2n=3 on Oops 090614#2n=3 on Oops 090614#2Blogo-links « […]

  9. […] Comments 3.3 The limb field … on RTFMpas foutus « C… on RTFMOldcola on Oops 090614#2n=3 on Oops 090614#2n=3 on […]

  10. […] dimensions at a time and connecting dot. He also have tremendous difficulties when it comes to know where the lateral mesoderm plates come from. But any scientist interested on the avian heart formation must have seen at least one of these […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: